Mattison’s City Grille Downtown Sarasota

1 N Lemon Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236, USA

About Mattison’s City Grille Downtown Sarasota

4.2 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

Jeannie Mang
March 22, 2022

Great place! Bar tender was awesome and band was great! This was my post 2 years ago! Gave 5 stars! My husband and I have been coming here every time we come to Florida. in fact last week we brought our daughters for dinner. Tonight we decided to come for drinks and listen to the band. We had met a couple earlier in the day and recommended to come here. they met us there. We were told we needed to move since we weren't ordering dinner, to only have a couple seated that didn't order food.. pretty sure they were friends with the manager and his friends wanted that table. I now give this place 1 star!

May 16, 2022

Visited this place at 4pm on a Friday and was greeted by an odd stench while I was sat at one of their outdoor tables. We had a nice waitress; she offered us free dessert after one of us told her how horrid the food was. Apparently some of these guys' food isn't too shabby, but my party might've just happened to purchase the three worst items on their menu. The pizza: unbelievably doughy, and the sauce tasted like ketchup. The sushi: not so sure if it was even fish. tasted super watery. And the fried chicken. Oh, the fried chicken! Fried chicken that could believably pass as scrap cardboard. Fried chicken that you couldn't even bite into without triggering your gag reflex. Fried chicken with black and gray spots all over. Fried chicken that seems like microwaved leftovers from a 2001 McDonald's dumpster. Don't eat here unless you're a long-time fan (which I don't foresee many people becoming). A horrible first-impression of Sarasota's cuisine.

Dave Heymann
May 01, 2022

All of the seating is outside but under roof. Tropical vibe with live music. Had the soup of the day and meatloaf. They were excellent! Service was great. My wife had the salmon and it was great. Drinks had a lot of alcohol in them. Highly recommended.

greg peck
February 14, 2021

My wife and I wandered in on our first day in town and were pleasantly surprised by the friendliness of our server Emily. She was welcoming, and efficient and made several helpful suggestions. The food and atmosphere were excellent and got our visit off to a great start! Thank you

susan caruso
February 28, 2021

Second time eating here. First time was quite good. Scallops were excellent. This time...Had the half order of scallops. They cut the scallops in half. Chewy and overcooked. The risotto was undercooked. Others ordered pizza. It looked great, but was flat in flavor and there was so much cornmeal on the bottom that it was gross. Too much cornmeal in your ovens. Need to do better.

Mattison’s City Grille Downtown Sarasota

Our Address

1 N Lemon Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236, USA

Can't Find an Artist or Business Here?

For more information on claiming your FREE listing, Submitting an Artist, a business or how SWFLMusic can help you reach your audience, please contact us today!